Going in to The Great American Bash 1996, the Four Horsemen were one man short. By the end of the evening, the Horsemen added not one, but two people to their roster.

In a move that was sure to enrage Randy Savage, Elizabeth and The Horsemen used his "alimony money" to bribe Steve "Mongo" McMichael to join the ranks of The Four Horsemen. He brought along with him his lovely wife Debra! During Ric Flair's match against The Macho Man, it became evident that Randy was going to do whatever it took to finish off The Nature Boy. After delivering his flying elbow, Savage quickly ascended the ropes for another drop. Woman, Elizabeth and Debra quickly got in the ring to block the move but Savage jumped anyway, forcing the women to scurry out of the ring. Chris Benoit, Steve McMichael, and Arn Anderson quickly stormed the ring to beat on Savage, forcing the referee to rule the bout a no contest.